| This letter was sent to the Boston Globe on March 18. Although the Globe has chosen not to print it, my personal soapbox has plenty of space. |
|
March 18, 2002
Monday's article describing the use of GPS and red light cameras questions whether there is a privacy issue given that certain information, such as a license plate, is already plainly visible. The privacy violation would be minor if not for concerns not mentioned in the article: data mining, dossier building, and other tracking by those with access to the raw data. Simply put, placing cameras at enough intersections permits the government to identify the approximate location of any car by noting where the car was last seen. By placing car sightings in a database with date and time, the track a car takes through the city can be determined quite easily and retained indefinitely. Vehicles in proximity to crimes could be identified long after the fact, whether or not they were involved. A quiet payoff by a suspicious spouse could reveal where the family car goes during the day. The city could find cars that reached one intersection too soon after passing another and issue speeding tickets, even though the traffic lights were green. Similar concerns exist with the automatic license plate reader the Boston Transportation Department is experimenting with to identify parking scofflaws, and the privacy problem quickly grows even further by combining information from all of these sources. These types of privacy issues are rarely noted by the media, yet they are far more insidious than the mere possession of a photo of a driver going through a red light, and they are technologically feasible. As these systems become widely deployed, it will be the job of the public to keep the abuse of public information in check. There is no need for the government to be able to compile dossiers of activities of law-abiding citizens at will and after the fact; yet until the privacy issue is laid out on the table, acknowledged, and dealt with, law enforcement will inch closer to its holy grail of knowing not just where we all are, but where we have been.
Copyright ©2001 by Patrick Madden, all rights reserved.
|